From Penn & Teller's MasterClass

Cause and Effect

Magic oversimplifies and distorts the principles of cause and effect. In this chapter, Penn & Teller discuss the philosophical aspects of cause and effect in relation to magic and the human psyche.

Topics include: Causality: The Red Ball

Play

Magic oversimplifies and distorts the principles of cause and effect. In this chapter, Penn & Teller discuss the philosophical aspects of cause and effect in relation to magic and the human psyche.

Topics include: Causality: The Red Ball

Penn & Teller

Teach the Art of Magic

Learn More

Preview

[MUSIC PLAYING] - I've bridled against the cause and effect in magic a lot. And every time I have, I've failed. It really seems like you need to punctuate the story and you need to have something for them to ride onto. It always seems to me on paper, and it always seems to me when I'm spending time thinking about tricks that there's something kind of profound about there not being cause and effect because it probably isn't cause and effect in the real world. There's no compelling argument for the being any free will whatsoever. The idea of cause and effect is no more real than my appearance here. We're clouds of molecules, and we're making an image in our heads. None of that has any sort of bearing on what's happening in the real world. But the thrust of the way we live our lives, the way we are forced to have the illusion of free will-- Christopher Hitchens was not the first to say it. Sartre said it. And it goes back much farther than that. But do you believe in free will? I have no choice. We need to believe in free will to live. And part of that, part of built into the way we live in order to remain sane is cause and effect. And in magic, you have separated cause and effect. You have a false cause and an unrelated effect, very often. - If we do a magic trick and we don't give the audience some sense of what the make-believe cause is, or what the real cause is, or what any kind of cause is, the magic trick fails, whether it's pure poetry-- there's a trick that that I've done for a long time in which I cut a rose apart by slashing its shadow. Now, that certainly isn't the way things work in real life. But it is a poetic idea that's kind of cool. And when you see the petals of the rose going and slashing and then, later on, me cutting my fingertip, and now my shadow bleeds, that cause and effect is a kind of beautiful, cool thing. We've turned that a little bit inside out many, many, many times. - If you try to say this is something that just happens, it becomes incredibly unsatisfying. The one that broke my heart, really broke my heart, was you do a thing where you vanish a cell phone, and it appears inside a fish, a borrowed cell phone. And I was in love with the idea that the vanish of the phone would just be a vanish of the phone. It would just vanish. So you've got an audience member and the two of us on stage. You've got six hands. You got people moving. You hold the phone, you hold the phone, you hold the phone, you hold the phone. The phone is in plain sight with the whole audience all the time, and then all of a sudden it isn't. And you don't know if the audience member had it last, or I had it last, or Teller had it last, where it went. Just it's gone. It was terrible. It was terrible. The audience couldn't perceive that the phone was gone. They couldn't perceive it as a trick. They didn't have a moment for it. It was just terrible. I do not like when the wand hits and there's the moment it's gon...

Open your mind with magic

With more than 40 years performing together, Penn & Teller have sold out shows around the world, earned a star on Hollywood’s Walk of Fame, and created the longest-running headline act in Las Vegas. Now the legendary magicians are taking you behind the curtain. Learn fundamental magic tricks and the psychological tools that create amazement, at home or on stage. Expand your perception of the possible.

Reviews

4.7
Students give MasterClass an average rating of 4.7 out of 5 stars.

Loved this class. Never would have thought to take a magic class but I watched the preview of it and couldn't resist. I loved not only learning the magic tricks but also Penn and Teller's discussions of magic, particularly on the ethics of magic. Wonderful.

Very good but could have used more magic content

I'm a skeptic that routinely investigates ghost hunters and other paranormal "believers"... understanding how magic tricks are done is an important skill for me.

This was such a fun course to take! I loved learning the basics of magic, and especially am excited about the card tricks that I learned. Overall, such a wonderful, well-thought out class with exceptional instructors. I can't wait to perform for my friends!

Comments

A fellow student

The coin trick teller that teller described is a thing. The trick is created by zee but I don’t now if it is for sale I have just seen him do it.

Margaret M.

The discussion about how effects are unsatisfying without a "magic moment" makes me think of Stranger in a Strange Land (if I've got the right book here). Mike Smith could actually vanish objects, but his magic tricks weren't impressive because he didn't "sell" them.

Joaquin Kotkin @MediaBarba

Aristotele said :" Theater is the imitation of action in the form of action" Teller: "MAGIC is the imitation of an IMPOSSIBLE action in the form of action"

Nicholas G.

That may have been a little too abstract for me — and I have a master's degree in rhetoric, along with a bachelor's degree in philosophy! I get that Penn is alluding to David Hume's (and others') critique of perception, but I do not at all understand what he means by the notion of a magic trick without cause and effect. Kant and Hume were both correct to note that cause and effect are elementary (even if illusory) aspects of all possible experience. "All possible experience" obviously includes the experience of the apparently impossible (i.e. magic), so I have no idea what Mr. Jillette is on about when he seems to say that he has a private concept of magic that does not include cause and effect. I wonder if HE even knows what the phrase "magic without cause and effect" means! You may as well speak of water without wetness. In other words, magic without cause and effect is not just a bad entertainment idea; it is a totally unintelligible idea. To say you like magic, but would rather it see it done without cause and effect, is like saying you enjoy circles, but only if they are made entirely out of straight lines. It's not just misguided; it is a priori absurd. It is demonstrably absurd BY THE VERY DEFINITION of the terms used. So why did these guys need to empirically test an outright absurdity by trying to vanish a cell phone without offering the audience a discernible cause for its disappearance? And since this discussion centers on an unintelligible dilemma, why was it at all worth having?