From Billy Collins's MasterClass

Reading: Connecting With Poetry

A poem is not a cookbook. Learn how embracing nuance and ambiguity can be your greatest ally when reading poetry.

Topics include: Ambiguity in “The Road Not Taken” by Robert Frost · Interpretive Pressure · Leave Your Footprints in the Margin · A Cautionary Tale Against Interpretation

Play

A poem is not a cookbook. Learn how embracing nuance and ambiguity can be your greatest ally when reading poetry.

Topics include: Ambiguity in “The Road Not Taken” by Robert Frost · Interpretive Pressure · Leave Your Footprints in the Margin · A Cautionary Tale Against Interpretation

Billy Collins

Teaches Reading and Writing Poetry

Learn More

Preview

[MUSIC PLAYING] - If poetry makes you tense, and I know it makes a lot of people tense, and one reason it does is that there's a frustrating way to look at it. That is that you know you read English well. And you speak English. That's your native language. And you know this poem is in English. And yet you have no idea what it means. Poetry asks for more participation on the part of readers than any other form of writing, I think. And you could arrange all of writing on a scale. And on this side of the scale, you would have writing that's always totally clear. There's no instability. And then you would move over to the other side where you would have writing where the meaning is very unstable and ambiguous. So over on the far, clear side, you might have a cookbook. And so when it says in a cookbook add 1 cup of sugar, you don't stop and say, well, what's she getting at there? I mean, sugar in what sense of the word? You just add the sugar. But if you move over through, well, journalism is interesting. The writing the law is interesting. People who write law try to make it as clear and as free of ambiguity as possible. Eventually, you'd get to literature. You'd get to the novel, and the drama, and everything. If you kept going all the way down to the end, you'd find poetry on the opposite end of the cookbook, where meaning is often double or the entendres are double. Someone said, poets are people who can't say one thing at a time. They are incapable of doing that. And that's one of the joys of poetry, I think. When you're young, and taking poetry in school, the fact that a poem can mean more than one thing is frustrating for a lot of students. They want an answer. And they want to get onto the next poem or get out of the class entirely. But I think a more mature reading of poetry or reader of poetry sees that ambiguity is a richening of the poem. It gives the poem more texture and more interest if a poem can support two or three readings. And usually, if there are alternate readings of a poem in a classroom, almost always those meanings are complementary, in other words, the poem can support both of them, rather than competitive, one has to be right. [MUSIC PLAYING] I'd like to read a poem by Robert Frost. And many people know this. It's one of his most famous poems. And it's considered to be a poem about making major decisions in your life. But it seems to mean that on the first reading. But I'll try to show you how it means something else on the second reading. Robert Frost, "The Road Not Taken." "Two roads diverged in a yellow wood. And sorry I could not travel both and be one traveler, long I stood and looked down one as far as I could to where it bent in the undergrowth. Then took the other, just as fair, and having perhaps the better claim because it was grassy and wanted wear. Though as for that the passing there had worn them really about the same. And both that morning equally lay in leaves no step ...

Let imagination lead the way

Known for his wit and wisdom, former U.S. Poet Laureate Billy Collins is one of America’s most beloved contemporary poets. In his MasterClass, Billy teaches you to appreciate the emotional pull of poetry. Learn his approach to exploring subjects, incorporating humor, and finding your voice. Discover the profound in the everyday, and let poetry lead you to the unexpected.

Reviews

4.7
Students give MasterClass an average rating of 4.7 out of 5 stars.

Similar to a cooking class where the chef starts with cookware and cuts a sheet of paper with a chef's knife before actually cooking anything. Here we get the essentials up front and the actual poems appear later on. I thought at first that he was less energetic than I would have wanted, but the content of the class is compelling enough to make me listen without the need for commercial flair.

Collins offers an accessible path to reading and writing poetry. The task seems doable when it's broken down into friendly pieces. The class has given me ideas about how to approach poetry writing as well as channels through which I can teach poetry writing to high school students.

Because of this course, I am more aware of the reader. I have learned ways to invite the reader into a poem in the first few lines. With a very easy and humorous style, Billy Collins addresses the complexity and mystery of poetry in ways which are making me rethink my craft.

Now I have a better understanding how to read poetry, what to look for in it and what not.

Comments

Kaerla F.

I want to write and be the easier poet in part because that's just who I am - no deep and brooding rhymester, I - and in part because, tell me true, who really wants to be beaten with that rubber hose? I am what I am, take me for all in all.

Michael Conlon

I very much appreciate his supporting multiple interpretations of a poem, as long as they are supported by the text. I also appreciate his explanation of the shifting meaning of Frost's poem. However, in his enthusiasm to promote Frost new-gained determinism at the end, to me he forgets the title of the poem. It is not "The Road Taken" but "The Road Not Taken." For me, this poem has always been a "what if" message, and how you could go crazy with "what if's" since way "leads on to way," fork in the road to another fork. So the question becomes, how do you deal with all the choices you didn't make. After all, each one could be said to "make all the difference"...

Simon C.

One of the purposes of poetry may be that exact dialogue with the reader that comes from the ambiguity? And the continuation of this dialogue can be represented by the notes at the margin. From this class I've suddenly thought of this aspect as one of the biggest differences between poetry and other kinds of texts. By the way, reading poetry it's a skill that needs to be acquired with practice, or it may be difficult for a reader who is not accustomed to it to easily perceive all the communicational layers of it.

Tauna S.

I learned to read with a married pair of Brit x-pats. The books were Shakespeare, Sir Conan Doyle, and by the time I was ten, Ian Fleming became one of their new favorites. I spoke very strange English as a result of the earliest books and even after I learned a more modern way of speaking, my writing tended to be Iambic pentameter and rhymed...yes even prose. It is still very hard to get out of the pattern when I write, especially when I am tired. I am also an artist, and a workbook for drawing mentioned free flowing for art ideas. I applied it to writing. Took one word, and free wrote for ten minutes without any punctuation, anything that came to mind. It was the loosed I ever managed to write and I was able to get two separate poems out of it. Same subject, but totally different. This has reminded me to let go once in a while.

Nancy C.

I love the last part, where he says do not beat a confession out of the poem. Sadly, this is what students are taught in English classes across the country. I remember hating poetry in school, having to study it line by line, and answer the question "What does it mean?". Here, Billy Collins finally demystifies how we should be reading and enjoying poetry. Great lesson!

Saurav N.

I think this is the best class on filmmaking till now...way better than all the other classes in here....

Kasy L.

I loved this lesson. I considered Frost's "Road Not Taken" in a way I never even imagined before. Also, I loved Billy's "Introduction to Poetry." I'll have to try writing notes in the footnotes of poetry books. It'll be a nice change. Another great lesson!

Warren D.

Writing in the margins has long been my way of reading anything. I have books that I have read many years ago and find in interesting to read what I wrote in the margins of those books. In some cases, my opinions have changed and in others, they have grown more adamant. I enjoyed this lecture and the reading and analysis of poems.

A fellow student

I love the idea of a scale showing a cookbook on one end and a volume of poems on the other. It's a reminder to teachers to scaffold text readings to build students' confidence with interpreting language. Lack of scaffolding might explain why, as Collins says, reading poetry makes people tense.

Ann P.

Brilliant loved Billy Collins from the moment I met him about 8 years ago. Late start poet. This course is brilliant!